Small Rate Increase vs. Large Rate Increase: When Each Is the Right Move

Once a practitioner has decided that a rate increase is warranted, a second decision presents itself: how much? The choice between an incremental increase and a significant jump is not simply about comfort — it has different implications for what the rate communicates, how the transition feels, and what market signal is sent.

What nobody explains about how much to raise rates is that neither a small increase nor a large one is inherently better. What matters is which fits the actual situation — the degree of current misalignment, the practitioner’s inner relationship to the number, and what the work warrants.

What a Small Rate Increase Does

A small increase — say, moving from $200 to $225, or from $400 to $450 — is incremental. It reduces the financial gap between current and warranted pricing in small steps, which can feel more manageable both internally and in client conversations.

When a small increase is appropriate:
– The current rate is close to where it needs to be and a modest adjustment is what fits
– The practitioner is making their first rate increase and wants to build the muscle of the process without a dramatic jump
– The increase is part of a regular annual review rather than a correction of significant underpricing

The risk of the small increase:
A small increase made primarily because it feels safer than a larger one is not really a strategic decision — it is an anxiety management decision. How the strength vs need distinction affects the amount: if the rate is significantly below what the work warrants, repeated small increases extend the period of underpricing rather than resolving it. They also require repeated announcement and adjustment processes, each of which carries its own transition cost.

What a Large Rate Increase Does

A significant jump — moving from $150 to $300, or from $300 to $500 — compresses the gap between current and warranted pricing in a single move. It produces a more significant market signal and requires a more complete inner inhabiting of the new number.

When a large increase is appropriate:
– The current rate is significantly below what the work warrants, and incremental movement would leave it misaligned for years
– The practitioner’s inner preparation is sufficient — they can genuinely inhabit the higher number, not just aspire to it
– A repositioning is intended: the practitioner wants to attract a different type of client, and the rate is a primary mechanism for that shift

What a large jump communicates vs a small one: a significant rate change sends a more deliberate positioning signal than a small one. It communicates that the practitioner has made a considered decision about the level at which they are working — not simply adjusted for inflation.

The risk of the large increase:
A large jump made before the inner preparation is complete can be harder to hold when challenged. The practitioner who jumps to a significantly higher rate without genuinely inhabiting it may find the first pushback conversation more destabilizing than a smaller, better-prepared increase would have been.

The Deciding Question

Questions that help determine the right amount: the most useful question is not “what increase can I tolerate?” but “what rate does the work actually warrant, and am I currently at a significant distance from it?” If the distance is significant, a larger jump with proper preparation is usually more efficient than a series of small adjustments. If the distance is modest, a smaller adjustment is appropriate and sufficient.

Preparation before any increase regardless of size: the preparation process is the same regardless of increase size. The inner work of inhabiting the number, the external work of updating all touchpoints, and the pre-decided grandfathering policy are all required whether the increase is $25 or $200.

The size of the increase matters less than the practitioner’s genuine inhabiting of the new number. A large increase that is fully inhabited is easier to hold than a small one that was chosen primarily to avoid the discomfort of a larger one.

The Abundance GPS Skool community helps practitioners arrive at the right number for their specific situation. Join us here.